Many great points are being expressed on this one. It kinda feels like when you're about to start a really LONG journey but don't have a map . . . yet you know you must journey. It starts one foot at a time and one in front of the other. I'm glad someone has started the process.
I've seen seen some major changes in the meat industry during my years on the job, which included a 30-year stint at a major supermarket, where I worked as the meat manager. I saw my team of meat cutters decimated after stores moved from butchering quarters of meat to boxed meat, the respect & pride the job once commanded doesn’t seem to be there anymore. A lot of members here are a older age group, we were workhorses and there isn't many workhorses coming up behind us. There’s not enough money in it and it’s a labor-intensive job which means young people are few and far between that will work it.
Two of my coworkers are 18 or 19. A clerk and a clean up guy. They're OK.
I could be wrong. I'm wrong a lot but I'm not sure if there's a problem with the work ethic of young people today anymore than there ever was. I remember hearing this same stuff back in 1978. Older people talking about how lazy the young people are. I'd like to think I was an exception, but I can't judge myself. Ask my old boss. Good workers are hard to find. They always have been and always will be.
Maybe I'm not old enough. There may have been a genuine "good old days" I wasn't working prior to 78. However, I've known a lot of lazy old people.
Quote-"Each contract we agree to allow more and more pre cut meat." What planet do you live on? The days of unions telling companies how to run their business are long over. We got rid of union job classifications long ago. Cutters learn how to participate in various jobs including wrapping, packing and clean up. Shipping and recieving employees load and drive trucks for deliveries. Cross training helps maintain and improve your companies chances to survive in the highly competitive, brutal business enviorment of today. Stop by Costco and watch the employes cut 60 pounds of trimmed strips and ribeyes in 5 minutes by machine Nobody complains about the quality of meat in Costco. They rave. The meat area employees are cross trained, do various jobs like trimming , machine operations, wrapping, placing meat in the cases and politely answering questions. You can even get a custom cut product if you ask. Your employer is not your competition. Costco is your competition. And from the sound of it, they are going to eat your lunch.
I think Big Industry as well as Mom and Pop store should teach those who are willing to learn the fine art of Butchery.. I have love old school Butchery for as long as I can remember, but because It is very male dominated I choose to obtain an education in Human Resource Management and Labor Relations. With over 17 years, H.R. experience I was laid off and I have ventured to pursue my aspiration as a Butcher.
I have been apprenticing in a local (Mom & Pop) Butcher shop that caters to specific cuts of meat. Nonetheless, out of the 10 Butcher Shops I asked for a free apprenticeship this particular shop was the only one that said “YES”. When the owners (Men) see me, they ask me “Why you (a girl) wanted to be a butcher? Then all the guys stop and stare!!
I tell them that I am passionate about the job, determine to offer the customer quality; I am willing to take direction, and what I lack in education I will make up in determination and perseverance. I am willing to stand in the freezing cold for 40 hours a week, carry and assist other in loading and unloading meat product and most of all offer great customer service in exchange for education and experience. Experience is priceless!!! I want to know where my food is coming from. I want to have the capability to explain to the customers the various cuts of meat and its function. I am willing to apprentice for free to show the owner that I am serious. Still!!! only one place has given me a shot.
I even created a resume explain my transition from HR to my Butchers Apprenticeship which I have sent to various shops. I have yet to hear anything but, I will not give up and I am determined to be a skillful Butcher. February will be on year of actual Butcher hands on education.
In my spare time, I purchase my own meat to cut and I read many book, I am studying diagrams and I look at YouTube videos for my education. I really need to obtain an opportunity, (be it paid or unpaid), with a Skilled Butcher to learn how to cut all types of meat. I currently do not get opportunities cuts skirt steaks, New York strips, or t-bones. I also know the dangers involved. (I absolved the owners from any liability). I have just started cutting oxtails on the electric band saw. AWESOME!!
I writing all this to say that if I put forth this much effort to learn, in addition to continuing my pursuits no matter the obstacles , then Meat Markets and Butcher Shop owners can invest time in those that really want to learn. As a result, we can have many generations of skilled Butchers. In the future I would love to have my own Butcher shop and when this dream comes to reality fruition, I promised myself I will train those who have a keen determination to do this type of work no matter their gender, age, or ethnicity. It takes a special person to do this job and I am that person, you will not get a complaint from me. I love being a Butcher!!
This is bought over from LinkedIN where I have this same post,
Bill Bateman
Sales manager Global Meats
Columbus, Ohio Area
If you were a young person entering the job market and had a choice between becoming a plumber at 20.00 per hour and no nights or weekends,or a butcher making 14.00 per hour working days,nights and holidays. Hard choice,maybe a few incentives!
This drives me nuts!! Because people like me who are doing it for the love of the trade get over looked because owners have been burned!!I believe that if you are doing a job that you love good money will eventually come.But, there is a great feeling of satisfaction, gratification, that I get from delivering a great service to the community. The butchers shop is not just a butcher shop. Just like a barbershop is not just a barbershop.It is also a connection with the community and camaraderie, weather it is in a super market or a small shop.
Apoc, I think a lot of the problem for labor does stem from the money aspect, i worked as a journeyman cutter for shursave for 9 months, having a high ability and a lot of free-way from my upper, i was able to learn a lot about the industry, though most of it is in relation to box-cut beef.
I was only getting paid 10.50 an hour, I asked for a raise, and I got fired and replaced within the same day, most of what irks me about the experience with any supermarket is management, they want to treat people who are basically in the cold, living in very terrible conditions 8-12 hours a day (forced over time), for basically no pay, and they will take just about anyone to do it.
I couldn't handle the cold anymore, the constant cutting room temperature of close to 30 degrees, directly under a cooling unit, I couldn't stand it any longer, not for the cheap wages i was making, and sure I don't want a company to pamper me right off the bat, but at the very least, give me some incentive to stay, my insurance is obviously horribly over-priced, on top of gas money, and car insurance, i was saving only about 50 bucks a week, and most of that savings went to former schooling bills.
In short, the typical worker gets absolutely destroyed in a supermarket environment, in fact i can say on the typical for work relations, no drug tests, etc, that most supermarket environments are dictated by prescription pills, stoners, and alcoholics, coping just barely to make a **** end wage, at a dead end job.
To fix this problem, obviously there needs to be more rigorous litigation on cutters, and what being a meat cutter truly implicates, a union at the very least with lobbyists, in a government sector dictating the policies, because honestly and truly i've had inspectors turn blind eyes to my company in Conghyham, PA, A shursave that is riddled with mold, a cracked freezer, and frequented by mice. At the end of the day, who is taking care of my sorry ass while i'm frost bit.
I opened up a few claims against the company but as of yet, nothing has stuck, not even better business, or the FDA.
At the end of the day, the job is pretty ****ty for young kids looking for something worthwhile, as at the very best i could end up like my boss, who was 25 years in the industry making only 16.50. (to hell with that)
8 hours in 0-30 degree temperatures, where the motivated get punished for working too fast, and if you do in fact finish too early, get sent home, miss 4 hours of pay, Dunno. I love the work, I just hate all the excesses to it that go absolutely unchecked.
-- Edited by Melnick on Saturday 7th of January 2012 04:07:15 PM
This is bought over from LinkedIN where I have this same post,
Karl Moorehead
Operations Specialist at SUPERVALU
I cut meat for 27 years and then went into the office as a meat supervisor and am now a store director. My take on it is- we don't really have an apprenticeship program anymore. We just throw people in and hope they swim. I trained as an apprentice for 2 years, was an assistant meat manager for 5 years before getting my own shop. Thats completely unheard of now a days. Investing in training is the key, from the basic skill of cutting, merchandising, ordering, and how to make a gross profit. I see companies spending lots of money running around trying to fix problems in the meat department and never really getting much accomplished because the person running the department doesn't have the basic skills of those components mentioned earlier. A good meat operation is crucial to a successful store as well as fresh in general. The industry has done this to themselves. What steps will they take to correct it?
It has been my experience in NYC that if you are not a friend of friend, then people don't want to invest the time and effort in someone they don't know. So it is a minor obstacle, but feel I can get pass that aspect.However many job posting say experienced Butchers, Head Butchers, and Meat cutters. I have yet to see Butchers Apprentice or Butchers Assistant, should I stop being intimidated and just submit my resume anyway?
As far as what constitutes what a butcher does, and being a workhorse, etc. A lot of you guys are just playing dumb to the fact that everyone is taking cuts everywhere, except skilled workers, and if you don't consider what you do as skilled, and or skillful, in dealing with the customer, management, handling sharp objects, and doing this all in colder temperatures at the crack of dawn, damn near 365 days out of the year, you have to be out of your mind,
Everyone wants to screw the younger generation, and it's that philosophy that has kept you older gentleman in the field for so long, and has kept anyone else out, which has a lot to do with a lot of other industries, the older generation doesn't want to lay down, and because of this, all the tiered systems are erased, the chances of having replacements is diminished and the notion that there will be another generation to step up as a meat cutter is practically absent, because most of you have signed contracts, and union agreements to basically put a stop to your own industry, whether it be for the rights of you to punch out earlier over your co-workers or for you to step out before cleaning the room starts, it must be nice to have such a cushy position and only dealing with the aspects of your work that are enjoyable while the rookies take it amongst themselves for 10.00/hr to baby sit your messes after you're headed home.
Did you work 25 years to get that sort of respect or did you do the same thing, in a time where inflation wasn't an issue, and you were still getting paid a decent wage to do it?
Don't play your butchery expertise to the sacrifice of any level of decency or humanity, if you've been in a freezer, you know the numbness associated with it, and you know a lot of supermarkets don't enforce drug laws, and i know a lot of you do self-medicate on top of other things just to stay sane, and in that regard, why should these younger kids have to suffer any level of that self deprecation at the hands and accounts of generations passed?
Should take a good hard look in the mirror, and consider how many rookies have passed through filled with piss and vinegar ready for the challenge but fell short because of bad policies, bad working conditions, and short wages, yet you always have this older gentleman ready to step in for nickles on the dime that gets servants instead of co-workers.
Fairness of the trade? or inner bias and an unwillingness to procreate the second generation, I feel at any rate these two things will ultimately destroy the industry itself, on top of micro-management, and typical drama associated with the brain lapse of sitting in cold temperatures longer then two hours a day. I find it somewhat pathetic to assume that the younger generation isn't a generation of workers, I'm 22 years old, and I've worked damn near 33 different jobs since turning 18; varying from baker,deli, meat, and now in my current industry of mining, which by the way started my wages just shy of 23/hr. oh, and sadly the working conditions are better. :)
wow. Never seen it put that way before. i am seriously impressed and think alot of that is true.. when I was at Giant all the union cutters were full time 25 or more years experience. they all got 5 weeks of paid vacation . they made more money than i ll ever dream of making as a meat cutter. they had amazing health coverage including vision and dental. they didn't have to pay anything for that stuff. . They got paid time and a half just for coming in on sundays and standing there for 6 hours. Us newer guys would get hired thinking all that was going to happen to us too but NO. the union contract changed. anyone hired after 2005 would not get all those great benefits. It really made some of us bitter. then they started quitting .. one went into pest control, . i went to another store because Giant wouldn't give me more than 20 hours a week all of sudden. . I think alot of that is going on everywhere. Its really not a surprise that younger kids are not interested in cutting meat for a living. Good for them. if they are young enough to find something better i hope they do. unfortunately for me I am too old for changes all I know if this so i try to make the best of it.
There's a lot of truth in Karl's post. Years ago we had a contractual limit of 1 apprentice for every 6 journeymen but that is no longer the case. Nowadays the chain I used to work for brings in "apprentices" just to lower the overall wage percentage of the dept. There seems to be no real intent to turn them in to skilled journeymen and in fact under the latest contracts the most they will ever be is a Class B meat cutter, NOT a journeyman.
He's also right about unskilled meat managers. When I was in the business most meat managers, or Chief Journeymen as they are called in a union shop, were the best of the best. However as time went by, contracts got worse, dept hours were cut, there were less and less incentives to be or stay a meat manager. I did because I needed the additional pressure and stress to keep from becoming bored, but many of the old timers, having plenty of seniority, stepped down. Meat manager became the only way for a newbie part timer to ever get full time, so it was only part timers who applied. Most of those were woefully unqualified but they are the only ones interviewing for meat manager so that is how it went.
Well said Sawman. In the old days I managed 18 cutters and apprentices and 6 meat wrappers in my dept. Then we went from hanging quarters to boxed beef, fresh whole chicken to pre-cut and packaged chill pack, and eventually much of the beef, lamb and veal would come in cut and packaged. My company actually removed most of the equipment except for the service grinder. But then sales went down the toilet, the company realized it's mistake and went back to at elast cutting bef, pork, lamb, and veal in the store.
However you cannot turn back the clock. As more and more discounters came up, like BJs, Walmart, Costco, etc, the traditional supermarkets are struggling to stay alive. This is why pay has decreased so much, union shop or not. It does unions no good to hold out for high rates if it just forces companies into bankrupticy.
Times change, economies change, and this is why I changed careers after 28 years in the business.
You are correct in all the skills you list as being required of retail meatcutters.
However as to having the smarts to do something else, don't sell yourself short. I was a meat manager for 24 of my 28 years in the business before I had had enough and changed careers. I became an optical networking engineer and in fact a Director of Engineering for a large telecommunications company. I've been doing this for 12 years and I have often remarked to my peers how much easier this business is than being a meat manager. I've also often told my engineers and techs that they really don't know what real work is; what we do is like going to school and getting paid for it!
The fact is, being a journeyman meatcutter is a highly skilled trade, but here's the rub: you have to do it in a highly competitive retail environment. Discount operators have dropped the bottom out of the labor market. Traditional chains who were always willing to pay decent wages to journeymen (alright sometimes with prodding from unions) now have no choice. The biggest variable in their cost structure is labor. They can only do so much with technology to lower their utility bills. They can't lower their store leases. Yet they HAVE to lower their costs in order to compete or they will go out of business. I urge young people considering meat cutting to look at something else. Welders and Machinists are in high demand today even in the recession, and many are starting at $30/hour right out of trade school. That's just 2 examples. Perhaps if it gets to the point where companies are desparate for meat cutters the market will someday come back. The way I look at it, considering the skill required, the hard work, the working conditions, the risk of injury, experienced Journeyman meat cutters should be getting $40 an hour today, but they aren't.
If you REALLY want to pursue a career in the meat business, don't be discouraged by job postings/want ads. They are like a Christmas wish list. Employers usually do not expect to get everything they ask for.
This is a real problem in Austarlia especially in Queensland. Money is the problem here with mining booming big money is being paid at the mines with the hourly rate being 4 times that of a butcher and the mines will train you. There is a lack of young people taking on butchering however it is good to see more females are getting into the industry and are shpwing up in awards and other competitions for their efforts.
I think "muscles" has the record for the most years (19) between first and last major (singles) tournament wins. He won the Australian Championships in 1953 and Australian Open in 1972 and a lot of others in between.
Looking forward to the Open starting in about a week.
This is bought over from LinkedIN where I have this same post,
Wally B.
Director Of Meat Operations at Fresh Encounter, Inc.
Toledo, Ohio Area
Without a doubt this is a problem! We have combated this problem by initiating an Apprenticeship Program and hand picking the talents that we have within to fill these needs. We train and teach these associates our ways of working the retail Meat Business. We have found this to be a very effective program.
This is bought over from LinkedIN where I have this same post,
Jan-Pieter Schotanus
Account Manager at Stoppelberg
Netherlands
The profession is totally undervalued but we overvalue people who don't want a job and keep on putting there hands up for unemployment benefits. Furtheron we established an economic environment were we all want more of the luxuray goods and pay less for food, therefore the food branche cannot afford qualified employees anymore and have to bring in forreign employee's. They work hard for less money (RESPECT) but it is no fun working with people you cannot understand is it?