As Young Men Flee Europe's Craft Economy, Tradeswomen Emerge
By Molly Moore
Washington Post Foreign Service
LYON, France -- Stephanie Gerbier goes to work dressed for combat: She wears body armor under her white apron, steel-reinforced shoes and a metal glove on her left arm. Her weapon of choice is a flat, razor-sharp knife.
She can truss up a garnet-red round of beef to look as exquisite as a gift-wrapped jewelry box, carve $17-a-pound veal scallops so thin that the pink slices are nearly translucent and extract precision cuts from a 660-pound side of beef.
For those skills, the 23-year-old Gerbier this year became one of the first two women to win France's annual competition for best apprentice butcher.
Gerbier is breaking cultural barriers in a trade that mirrors the transformations in the European workplace of the 21st century: The attraction of prestigious white-collar and high-tech professions has steered young people away from Old World artisanal crafts, many of which traditionally have been open only to men for centuries. As a result, women are more able to enter trades that were largely closed to them.
Facing a shortage of as many as 5,000 butchers, France's historically macho meat industry has begun welcoming women. This summer, the national Federation of Butcher Shops is targeting women in a major recruiting drive -- and promoting Gerbier as one of its new female success stories in a field that now has about 100 female certified butchers, according to federation spokeswoman Cecile Mousset.
"The only drawback to being a woman butcher is that you can't carry heavy pieces of meat like a 90-kilo [200-pound] leg on your own," said Gerbier, who just earned her two-year professional aptitude certificate. "I always need to ask for help, but that's a minor inconvenience."
The butcher shortage comes as the French butcher shop -- considered by many French consumers to be the heart of the national culinary obsession -- is struggling to survive in the face of growing competition from supermarkets and an expanding fast-food culture. In the past three decades, France has lost nearly half of its butcher shops: 21,000 are open today, down from more than 40,000.
"People think that being a butcher is gross," said Gerbier, who wears her fawn hair in a ponytail and whose delicate fingers belie her ability to manhandle hefty chunks of pork, beef and lamb. "But it's not the case. We work in a very clean environment. The meat we get is washed before we work on it; it's not all bloody. People have misconceptions because of movies, but it's far from reality."
Gerbier is entering a trade far different from the one her professor, Serge Vialan, 53, joined a generation ago. He was sent to the slaughterhouse each week to kill the heifers and steers needed to stock his butcher shop. But that practice has been halted by rules the European Union imposes on member states.
In recent years, the E.U. has mandated dozens of other health and safety upgrades in this and countless other traditional occupations. For Gerbier, the changes include the body armor and regulations on precisely how shopkeepers must mop their floors. Today, largely because of E.U. rules, butchers can trace every slice of meat that leaves their shops, down to the animal's birthplace, the farmer who raised it, what it ate, when it was vaccinated, what illnesses it had and where it was slaughtered.
Even so, French butchers say the techniques of the traditional boucherie remain unchanged.
"I don't mean to sound nationalistic," said Vialan, who in addition to teaching helps conduct recruiting drives for butchers in local schools and community job markets. "But in France, we prepare meat with much more care than other countries. French cuisine is unique; the cuisine is so precise, you need to have a specific cut of meat for each particular dish."
A French butcher shop seems to have more in common with a pastry shop than with the butcher counters found in the United States. At the Maison Vessiere, where Gerbier is an apprentice, in a busy commercial neighborhood in the picturesque southeastern city of Lyon, the tournedos, côte de boeuf, veal scaloppini and merguez sausages are arrayed in the counter as meticulously as cakes and petits fours.
Gerbier said she developed a fascination with butcher shops as a young girl wandering the markets in the nearby village of Tassin. She often sneaked behind the counters to watch the butchers at work. When she told her parents she wanted to become a butcher, they ordered her to earn a high school diploma and take law courses instead.
She tried law; she tried working in insurance. She hated both. Two years ago, she signed up for a butcher's program without telling her parents.
"Like many people in our society, my parents looked down on apprenticeships," Gerbier said. When she confessed that she'd signed up for butcher school, "they said I wouldn't last, that I would give up quickly," she said. "Their criticism motivated me to prove that I could do it, even though it's not a job for women.
"It's more comfortable working in an office with air conditioning rather than in a refrigerator the way butchers do," she said. "Nonetheless, I would never go back to my previous life. I love everything about my job. I love cutting the meat, preparing it, the interaction with the clients, giving them cooking tips."
Training is rigorous. For each week in class learning theory, hygiene and E.U. regulations, students spend two weeks working in a butcher shop or behind a supermarket meat counter. Gerbier started on pork cutlets, among the cheapest pieces of meat. She spent a week mastering veal. She has spent months perfecting her work on lamb -- which requires precise cuts and is the most expensive meat in the shop.
She plans to continue studying for another two years for a more advanced certification, with courses that will include management and other skills for running a butcher business.
Her boss, Joel Lucas, 42, said that as a woman, Gerbier is a novelty to the customers: "In this field, people are used to seeing women serving food, but not cutting meat." Gerbier said she heard one client tell her boss, "You shouldn't leave your cute little butcher in the back; we'd like to see her out front."
But when she began winning local and regional meat-preparation competitions, she said, many once-supportive male colleagues at the Francois Rabelais butcher school -- where she is the only female student -- turned on her. Vialan, her professor, said he once found his only female student in tears over the barbs of male classmates days before the national competition.
"It was tough for her," Vialan said. "But I think she will inspire other women."
Each year, the Federation of Butcher Shops holds a competition for the 3,700 apprentices in butcher training. After local eliminations and six hours of slicing, carving and decorating, three trainees are selected as the year's top apprentice butchers. This year, two of the three were women -- the first time any woman made it to the top.
"My dad now brags about me with everyone," Gerbier said.
But at the end of the day, on her way home from the butcher shop, where does Gerbier -- who loves to cook -- buy her meat?
"I shop like anyone else and go to the supermarket," Gerbier said. "It's convenient to have everything in the same location."
Thats an Awesome Story! I know even when I attended the meat cutting school, some girls would sign up and they had a deli area to make meat and cheese trays and etc. The teachers tryed to push me over there and I threw a fit and said I came to learn to cut meat! They let me have at it. Thankfully Im tall and built for the job and I could carry the hindquarters myself.
hmmm if there is such a demand for butchers in france maybe i should go to france. they should be paying more if they need butchers so bad and I love working with women
my boss lady is just this little thing but she broke beef for 15 years at a slaughter house and worked retail for another 14 years after that. I am a good cutter but she makes me look bad when she cuts.
great story, I can relate lol. fdarn if she is that little I can relate to her to lol i'm a little thing but I can push a knife. guess for my size it was a good thing i miss the hanging stuff. batting eyes!!
-- Edited by littlebit_of_pleasure on Thursday 9th of June 2011 06:06:48 AM